Avoid taxes!
Can You Avoid Hawaii Car Rental Taxes by Renting Off-Airport?
A Reality Check on Off-Airport Rentals & Peer-to-Peer Alternatives
Before July 2014, Saving Money Off-Airport Was a Real Thing...
Over the years, we saved countless travelers hundreds of dollars by renting off-airport. So, what changed?
In 2014, the State of Hawaii enacted a facility surcharge of $4.50 per day at all off-airport locations. Over a two-week rental, that adds up to $63—and imagine how that impacts our long-term renters staying two to three months. While we used to compare airport versus off-airport rates with stunning savings, the gap has closed significantly.
Today's Reality: Transportation & Convenience Costs
Let's take a Maui car rental for example. We might be able to save you $50 a week renting in Kihei. However, Kihei is about a 25-minute drive from Kahului Airport (OGG). Since major car rental companies do not offer free airport shuttles to Kihei, you have to pay for rideshare or taxi transportation averaging $55 each way.
Time & Inconvenience Factors: Most off-airport locations close by 5:00 PM, creating major headaches for late-arriving flights. Taking public transport or paying for rideshares after a long flight just to save a few bucks often leaves visitors asking if it was really worth the extra stress!
What About Peer-to-Peer Rental Services & Independent Agencies?
Is it possible to bypass major rental brands, skip some airport fees, get picked up, and rent an older vehicle 20–30 minutes away? Yes, it is. But after 30+ years in this industry, we've heard countless holiday horror stories: vehicles with mechanical breakdowns, interiors that smell like ashtrays, or unexpected pest issues.
During peak seasons like Christmas, independent operators and individual vehicle hosts are usually completely sold out. If a private car breaks down or gets trashed, the average host has no backup vehicle to give you—leaving your family stranded and destroying your vacation!
Our Expert Advice (My Two Cents)
Major established car rental agencies are fully equipped with large fleets to swap out your vehicle immediately in case of a breakdown or unexpected issue. For true peace of mind on your Hawaii vacation, sticking with established, reputable brand names is always the safest bet.